Growth

    New website, same rankings: the checklist before you switch

    Moving to a new website doesn't have to cost you your Google rankings. Here's the checklist I'd follow before you switch, drawn from Google's own guidance.

    By Juno

    ·

    12 November 2026

    ·9 min read

    If your current website is dated but still brings in enquiries from Google, a rebuild can feel like a risk. That fear is reasonable. Rankings attach to page addresses, so if those addresses stop working, Google and your customers can lose the path to the right page.

    The short answer: You give your rankings the best chance by mapping every old page address to its closest new page, putting a permanent redirect in place, keeping the content that already ranks, and checking Search Console after launch. Google also asks you to submit a new sitemap and to keep the redirects in place, generally for at least a year.

    Why do websites lose rankings after a redesign?

    Google stores its index page by page. In a video on URL changes, Google's John Mueller puts it plainly: if you change the address of a page, that page's data has to be forwarded, otherwise it gets lost. It does not matter whether you are rebuilding the whole site or changing something that looks small, such as a trailing slash. Google treats these as site moves.

    That is why a redesign often goes wrong: the new site looks better, but the old addresses return an error, or they all point at the homepage, so it looks as if the new site killed the SEO when the missing piece was usually the mapping and the redirects.

    Google's site-move documentation also says you should expect temporary fluctuation in rankings while it recrawls and reindexes the site. That can happen even when the move is done carefully. The checklist below is about avoiding the losses you can avoid.

    A website rebuild is still often the right call when the current site is slow, hard to use or cannot do the job you need. The work is to change the design without throwing away the addresses that already earn their keep. If speed is part of why you are moving, see why a slow website costs you customers.

    What should you record before the old site comes down?

    Do this while the old site is still live. Once it is gone, some of this is much harder to recover.

    Start with a full list of current page addresses. Google says a practical place to begin is your sitemap, because that is often how the important URLs were submitted in Search Console. A sitemap is a list of your page addresses, usually at a URL such as yoursite.co.uk/sitemap.xml, which you give to Google so it can find your pages. Search Console is Google's free tool for seeing how your site appears in Google Search, including which pages are indexed and whether Google is hitting errors.

    Add the addresses that already bring traffic, from your analytics, your server logs, and the "links to your site" report in Search Console. Record the titles and headings on the pages that rank, and keep a copy of the content. Include files that already attract visits or links, such as images, PDFs and videos; Google's guidance says these need to be moved in the same way as ordinary pages. Then build a mapping: each old address beside the new address that should replace it.

    On a recent project we mapped every one of the old site's 193 page addresses before launch.

    What is a redirect, and which pages need one?

    A redirect is an instruction on your server that sends someone who visits an old address on to a new one. Done properly, it does the same for Google.

    Google recommends a server-side permanent redirect where you can use one. In its redirects documentation, the 301 and 308 status codes mean a page has permanently moved to a new location. Those are the ones to use for a site you are not planning to switch back. A 302 redirect is temporary. Google says it follows a temporary redirect but does not treat it as a signal that the new address should replace the old one in search results.

    Each old page should go to the closest new page, one to one. If you have merged several old pages into one new page, those old addresses can all go to that single new page. What you should not do is send lots of unrelated old addresses to the homepage. Google's site-move guidance warns that redirecting many old URLs to one irrelevant destination, such as the homepage, can confuse users and might be treated as a soft 404: a page that looks like a not-found error even if the server does not say so. Avoid long chains, where page A goes to page B and only then to page C. Google can follow a chain, but it advises redirecting to the final destination directly.

    What should happen on launch day?

    Before you point the domain at the new site, the mapping should already be finished and the redirects should be ready to turn on. Turn the permanent redirects on, and remove anything that was blocking the new site while it was being built. Google specifically warns people not to leave behind "noindex" tags or robots.txt blocks that were only needed during development. A robots.txt file tells crawlers which parts of a site they may look at; if you blocked the staging site, that block must come off the live site.

    Submit a sitemap of the new addresses in Search Console, then remove the old sitemap. If you are changing domain name, use the Change of Address tool in Search Console. You do not need that tool if you are staying on the same domain. Test a sample of old addresses, including a few that used to bring traffic, and confirm they land on the right new pages.

    How long until rankings settle, and how long should redirects stay up?

    Google's own documentation does not give a date by which everything will be back. It says to expect temporary fluctuation while it recrawls and reindexes. For medium-sized sites, it can take a few weeks or more for the new URLs to start showing, and longer for larger sites. How quickly this happens depends on how many addresses you have and how fast your server responds. Googlebot has to visit every URL on the old and new site at least once before Google will consider the move complete, and there are no fixed crawl frequencies.

    On redirects, Google says: "Keep the redirects for as long as possible, generally at least 1 year." That period is so Google can transfer signals to the new URLs, including recrawling and reassigning links on other sites that still point at the old addresses. From a user's point of view, it suggests considering keeping redirects indefinitely.

    What should you ask a web designer before you hire them?

    Hand this list to any designer or agency, including mine.

    • Will you export every current page address from the sitemap, Search Console and analytics before the old site comes down, and give me the list?
    • Will you map each old address to the closest new page, rather than sending everything to the homepage?
    • Will those redirects be permanent server-side redirects (301 or 308), and will you keep them in place for at least a year?
    • What will you do with the titles, headings and content that already rank? Can I see that those pages still exist on the new site?
    • Who will remove any staging blocks, submit the new sitemap in Search Console, and watch the index reports in the weeks after launch?
    • If something drops after launch, who is responsible for finding the broken redirects?

    If you are comparing firms, I have a wider piece on how to choose a digital marketing agency, plus notes on how long it takes to build a website and a website health check for the current site.

    A launch checklist you can copy

    The table below is a working checklist, checked against Google's site-move guidance on 12 November 2026.

    StepWhenWho does itWhy it matters
    List every old page address from the sitemap, Search Console, analytics and important files (PDFs, images)Before the old site comes downYou and your designerYou cannot redirect an address you have not recorded
    Note the titles, headings and content that already bring traffic or rankingsBefore the old site comes downYou, with your designerRankings attach to pages that still answer the same need
    Map each old address to its closest new address, one to oneBefore launchYour designer, with your sign-offStops old links and search results landing on the wrong page
    Turn on permanent server-side redirects (301 or 308) for every mapped addressLaunch dayYour designer or hostTells people and Google that the page has moved for good
    Remove staging blocks such as noindex tags or a robots.txt rule that was only there during the buildLaunch dayYour designerLeft in place, these can stop Google indexing the new site
    Submit a sitemap of the new addresses in Search Console, and test a sample of old URLsLaunch dayYour designer, or you in Search ConsoleHelps Google find the new pages and confirms the redirects work
    Watch Search Console and analytics for errors, and for traffic moving from old addresses to new ones. Update the links you control (internal links, Google Business Profile, social profiles and ads)After launch, first weeks and monthsYou and your designerGoogle says visibility may fluctuate. Watch the index reports for a rise in errors, and point high-traffic links straight at the new addresses
    Keep the redirects in place, generally for at least a year, and update the links you controlAfter launch, ongoingYou and your designerGoogle needs time to recrawl and transfer signals; users should not hit dead ends

    Source for the underlying steps: Google Search Central, "Site moves and migrations", last updated 20 August 2026, checked 12 November 2026. https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/site-move-with-url-changes

    What does this mean for your business?

    A new website should not mean starting again in Google. The work that protects you is unglamorous: a complete list of old addresses, a mapping, permanent redirects, and a few weeks of careful checking after launch.

    If you are replacing a site that already brings in some enquiries, I map every old page before anything changes. You can book a call with Tom.

    Sources

    Frequently asked questions

    Will I lose my Google rankings if I get a new website?

    Not automatically. Rankings are more likely to drop if old page addresses stop working, or if they all point at the homepage instead of the closest new page. Google also says some temporary fluctuation is normal while it recrawls the site. A careful mapping, permanent redirects and a check of Search Console after launch give you the best chance of keeping what you already have.

    What is a 301 redirect?

    It is a permanent server-side redirect. Google's redirects documentation says the 301 and 308 status codes mean a page has permanently moved to a new location, and that this is the type to use when you need the new address to appear in search results. A 302 redirect is temporary and is not treated as a signal that the new address should replace the old one.

    Should I redirect old pages to my homepage?

    Only if the homepage is genuinely the closest replacement for that old page. Google warns against sending many unrelated old URLs to one irrelevant destination, such as the homepage, because it can confuse people and might be treated as a soft 404. Map each old address to the new page that actually replaces it.

    How long should I keep redirects in place?

    Google says to keep them for as long as possible, generally at least one year, so it can transfer signals to the new URLs and recrawl links that still point at the old addresses. It also suggests considering keeping redirects indefinitely from a user's point of view, while updating the links you control so people are not delayed by an unnecessary hop.

    Do I need to tell Google about my new website?

    Submit a sitemap of the new addresses in Search Console, and use the Change of Address tool only if you are moving to a new domain or subdomain. You do not need that tool for a redesign that stays on the same domain. Search Console is also how you watch the move: indexed pages, errors and the shift from old URLs to new ones.

    Now taking on new clients

    Ready to never lose another customer?

    Book a 15-minute call. No pitch. If it's a fit, you're live in 14 days.

    Book a free call